Rebecca McDuffee McGeorge
- tpointmuseum
- 6 days ago
- 3 min read
Rebecca McDuffee McGeorge
The portrait of Rebecca McDuffee McGeorge is believed to have been painted by her niece's husband, Edward Curran Herrick.
Rebecca McDuffee was born in 1798, probably in Athens, the eleventh of twelve children of Daniel McDuffee (1752-1831) and Dorothy Ladley (1755-1845), both natives of County Antrim, Ireland. Rebecca's sister Anna McDuffee Tyler was the mother of Eliza Tyler Herrick, wife of the artist Edward Curran Herrick, and Mary Tyler Long, whose portrait Edward Herrick also painted.
Rebecca's parents immigrated to Bucks county, PA, about 1784. They moved to Athens in 1788. Daniel McDuffee worked as an agent for Col. Arthur Erwin, who had many land claims in what would become Bradford county. When Erwin died in 1791, McDuffee inherited much of his land.
Daniel McDuffee built a home on what is now Edward St.; it is referred to as the Herrick House.
Daniel McDuffee was a skilled weaver. The Tioga Point Museum has in its collection a coat of silk and linen woven by him for his son Ferdinand. The museum also has a ladies' straw hat made by Daniel's daughter Dorothy.
Rebecca married Horatio Thomas McGeorge Jr., probably about 1827. Horatio McGeorge was born in London, England, in October, 1783, the third of at least nine children of Rev. Horatio Thomas McGeorge Sr. (1755-1852), a Congregationalist minister, and Catherine Dickson (1760-1838). Horatio's parents immigrated to the United States about 1802. They settled first in Hadley, MA; they moved to South Oxford, NY, in 1820.
Horatio Jr. married Nancy McIntire in 1812 in Boston, MA. They had two children together:
Robert Leslie McGeorge (1816-1893)
Henry McGeorge (dates unknown)
Horatio and his family lived in Butternuts, Otsego county, NY, in 1820. Nancy presumably died in the 1820s.
Louise Welles Murray wrote the following about Horatio McGeorge in her 1908 History of Old Tioga Point:
... Cabinet maker ... Horatio T. McGeorge ... located here about 1830 [sic – probably a few years earlier]. He was an expert carpenter, his specialty being church building. He evidently came here to build the first Presbyterian Church. He was twice married; by first wife had Henry and [Robert] Leslie; then married Rebecca, daughter of Daniel McDuffee, a beautiful woman, mother of Frank and
Eliza, well known, though no longer resident at Athens. Mr. McGeorge was a fine musician and long played the organ and bass viol in the Presbyterian church, just north of which he had a house and shop for twenty years; later he lived and died on Paine Street, having become entirely blind. His daughter Eliza [1832-1917] married Rev. William French, at one time teacher in the [Athens] Academy, who later, for long years, did a wonderful missionary work on Blackwell's Island, gaining the well-deserved name of "Angel of the Island." His labors were shared by his wife, who still continues them. Mr. French, while at Athens, was largely instrumental in establishing Trinity Church.
Records show Horatio McGeorge's name on payment vouchers from the Athens Presbyterian Church.
Horatio must have come to Athens by 1827 (Rebecca's death notice in the Athens Gleaner says 1826). His first child with Rebecca, Frank H. McGeorge, was born in 1828. Frank was a dentist in Corning, NY, for many years. He died in Corning in 1912.
Rebecca and Horatio lived in Athens for the rest of their lives.
Horatio McGeorge died on Jan. 13, 1854, probably in Athens. He was buried in Tioga Point Cemetery.
After Horatio's death, Rebecca lived for a while with her niece Eliza Tyler Herrick and her family. In 1865 she lived in Corning with her son Frank. Later she lived with her daughter Eliza McGeorge French in Canterbury, Orange county, NY.
Rebecca McDuffee McGeorge died at her daughter's home on Feb. 27, 1870. She was buried with her husband in Tioga Point Cemetery.
References:
Murray, Louise Welles. A History of Old Tioga Point and Early Athens. Raeder Press, Wilkes-Barre, PA, 1908
Heverly, Clement C. Pioneer and Patriot Families of Bradford County. Bradford Star Print, Towanda, PA, 1913
Galpin, Henry J. Annals of Oxford, NY. Times Book and Job Printing House, Oxford, NY, 1906
Star-Gazette, Elmira, NY
Gleaner, Athens, PA
Journal, Corning, NY
KSR 8/19/2025






























Comments